Brothers Grimm Movie
Wednesday, August 11, 2010 at 11:58AM
While walking around the Mississippi district in Portland last night, I came across a used copy of Terry Gilliam's Brothers Grimm on DVD (I also picked up a copy of the horror-themed version of Snow White, but I'll write about that later). I snatched up the film because I have been intending to write about it since I started this new blog on horror fairy tales a few months ago.
When I first saw this film a few years ago, I felt very ambivalent about it, not because the film is a wild fantasy-version of the Grimm's lives (although that is a little strange and audacious), but because I felt like the fairy tale elements were downplayed in lieu of the main plot (the Brothers Grimm as sort-of Ghostbuster charlatans). Basically, the film didn't feel like a fairy tale to me because it attempted to string a bunch of fairy tale motifs into a longer plot-based narrative. During this viewing, I threw out those pre-conceived expectations and enjoyed the film a lot more. Mainly, I enjoyed the numerous fairy tale references and subtexts, many of which are very delightful to see portrayed with Gilliam's wonderful visual style, even if they are just fragments of fairy tales. In some ways, what I liked about this viewing is exactly what I disliked about the first viewing. Movie watching is an extremely subjective experience after all. There are a few things that don't make any sense in the film, not even within the context of this zany story-world (mainly the gingerbread-girl sequence--totally baffles me), but I appreciate the relentlessly fantastical and imaginative storytelling overall.
I enjoyed the allusions to Little Red Reding Hood and Hansel and Gretel, but I especially enjoyed the Snow White references, everything from the use of mirrors to the narcissistic queen and the girls sleeping in coffins. I think my favorite element is the use of werewolf folklore--I love how the werewolf is wearing a wolf pelt when he takes human form. Also, the use of torture devices in the film seemed fitting concerning how many witches are executed with torture devices at the end of the tales.
Some things clearly diverted away from the fairy tale tradition, like the horse with the spider webs and the use of insects in general (seemed more like The Mummy in the digital insect department), but overall I enjoyed the storytelling and the use of fairy tale elements to create an engaging horror comedy. I was definitely impressed by the writer's and director's knowledge of the fairy tales and their use of the gothic potential of fairy tales, and this was effectively paired with Gilliam's unique and boldly visual storytelling.
















